Type of article (1) research paper, (2) review paper,  (3) short note, (4) book review and other..


YES
NO
Comments
Is the article within the scope of the journal?



Is the aim or hypothesis clearly stated?



Are the materials and methods corresponding and clearly presented?



Does the work constitute an original contribution?



Is the quality of English language adequate?



Are the interpretations and conclusions supported by the presented data?



Are the main title and the abbreviated title accurate and informative?



Is the abstract accurate and informative?



Are the keywords appropriate?



Does the introduction satisfactorily explain the context and aims of the work?



Are the figures accurately described?



Are the figures necessary?



Are the figures clear and of good quality?



Are the tables necessary?



Are the tables of acceptable quality?



Are the equations accurate and informative?



Are the units appropriate?



Do the figure legends provide sufficient information?



Is the interpretation of data acceptable?



Are the references necessary?



Are the references sufficient?



Is the reference list in accordance with the instructions to Authors?





Additional Comments on the Manuscript for the AUTHOR(S) 




Accept without change
A
Accept after minor revision
B, C
Re-evaluate after major revision
D
Reject (please give reasons)
E

B - made by the editor
C - made by the author(s)




Please return to: IAS@mf.uni-lj.si

or post to the following address:
Image Analysis and Stereology Editorial Office
Institute of Anatomy, Medical Faculty
Korytkova 2
SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
Fax: +386-1-543-7301


Additional Comments on the Manuscript for the EDITOR




MS 
Referee No. 
Revision 
Page 1 of Evaluation Form: ADDITIONAL COMMENTS


Please mark your decision with an X in the appropriate box. If you cannot answer with yes or no put in NA (no answer). If you have additional comments, please mark the appropriate cell with an X under Comments and use forms 2/4 and 3/4.


MS 
Referee No. 
Revision 
Page 2 of Evaluation Form: ADDITIONAL COMMENTS


Please use additional pages if necessary.


MS 
Referee No. 
Revision 
Page 3 of Evaluation Form: RECOMENDATION





MS 
Referee No. 
Revision 
Page 4 of Evaluation Form: ADDITIONAL COMMENTS